For decades, petrol cars dominated roads worldwide, but the electric revolution is transforming how we calculate vehicle expenses. Understanding the true cost of running electric car vs petrol requires analyzing not just fuel prices, but long-term ownership economics. This comprehensive 2025 guide reveals where electric vehicles (EVs) deliver staggering savings and rare scenarios where petrol retains an edge.
Try Our Free Calculator : Cost of Running Electric Car vs Petrol
🔍 Upfront Purchase Costs: EV Premium vs Petrol Affordability
Electric cars still command higher initial prices globally. In the UK, EVs average £48,000–£50,873—over £28,000 pricier than the £21,964 average petrol car. Similarly, US buyers pay ~$56,000 for new EVs versus $49,000 for petrol models. This gap persists due to expensive battery technology, though three factors narrow it annually:
- Government incentives like the US $7,500 federal tax credit (available as an upfront discount)
- Salary sacrifice schemes (e.g., UK employees save 20–50% via pre-tax deductions)Â
- Plunging battery costs making smaller EVs (e.g., Dacia Spring) accessible at ~ÂŁ128/monthÂ
Table: Upfront Cost Comparison (2025)
| Vehicle Type | Avg. Price (UK) | Avg. Price (US) | Key Discounts |
|---|---|---|---|
| Electric Car | £48,000–£50,873 | $56,000 | Tax credits, salary sacrifice, grants |
| Petrol Car | ÂŁ21,964 | $49,000 | Dealer promotions only |
Try Our Free Calculator : Cost of Running Electric Car vs Petrol
⚡ Running Costs: Where EVs Dominate
Fuel Expenses
Electricity costs 3–5× less per mile than petrol. For 10,000 miles annually:
- EVs cost ÂŁ630–£780 using home charging (7–8p/mile)Â
- Petrol cars cost ÂŁ1,230–£1,450 (12–15p/mile)Â
Savings exceed £600/year in the UK and $1,000–$1,500 in the US 7. Geography matters: Iceland saves drivers £15.29/100 miles, while Austria sees only £0.66/100 miles saved
Maintenance & Repairs
EVs have 50% lower servicing costs due to fewer moving parts:
- Average EV service: ÂŁ165 vs ÂŁ205 for petrol
- Brake replacements are rarer thanks to regenerative braking
- No oil changes, exhaust fixes, or timing belt repairs
đź’° Tax Incentives: Hidden EV Savings
- UK Benefit-in-Kind (BiK): EVs taxed at 3% (2025), rising to 9% by 2029—still far below the 37% max for petrol cars
- Road Tax: Post-April 2025, UK EVs pay just ÂŁ10/year initially, then ÂŁ195/year—still 50%+ below many petrol equivalentsÂ
- Global exemptions: ULEZ/congestion charge avoidance (London), free parking, toll discounts
🌍 Long-Term Ownership Savings
Total Cost of Ownership (TCO)
Studies confirm EVs’ lifetime savings despite higher sticker prices:
- US: Save $6,000–$12,000 over the vehicle’s lifeÂ
- South Africa: Save ~R9,700/year ($530) fueling a Volvo EX30 vs petrolÂ
- Exceptions: West Virginia (90% coal power) and Maine offer minimal savings; Texas’ low petrol prices delay paybackÂ
Depreciation Trends
EVs now outpace petrol cars in value retention:
- 2025 residuals strengthened by petrol/diesel sales bans (e.g., UK 2030)Â
- Battery longevity: Modern packs last 20 years/186,000 miles, with <0.5% failure rates post-2016Â
*Table: 5-Year Cost Breakdown (10,000 Miles/Year)*
| Cost Factor | Electric Car | Petrol Car | Savings |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fuel/Energy | £630–£780 | £1,230–£1,450 | £600–£700 |
| Maintenance | £165/service | £205/service | 20–50% |
| Tax (BiK) | 3–9% | Up to 37% | £500+/year |
| Depreciation | Moderate (improving) | High (worsening) | Variable |
⚙️ Efficiency & Environmental Edge
- Energy Conversion: EVs use 60–80% of grid energy for motion; petrol cars waste 80% as heatÂ
- Grid Resilience: EVs add just 1% load to grids (e.g., California); smart charging prevents overloadsÂ
- Emissions: Even coal-powered EVs cut COâ‚‚ by 30% vs petrol; renewables boost reductions to 77%Â
🔧 Critical Considerations by Region
- Home Charging Access: Essential for max savings. Without it, lifetime costs rise $10,000–$26,000
- Electricity Sources: Renewables-heavy regions (e.g., Washington, Iceland) slash energy costs 70%
- Public Charging Costs: 3–4× pricier than home rates—still cheaper than petrol but less ideal
âť“FAQs: Cost of Running Electric Car vs Petrol
1. Do EV batteries need replacement often?
No. Failure rates are <0.5% for post-2016 models. Batteries retain 85–90% capacity after 100,000 miles 8.
2. Are EVs really greener with coal-powered grids?
Yes. Even in coal-dominant West Virginia, EVs use 33% less energy and cut emissions 30%
3. Can the grid handle mass EV adoption?
Absolutely. EVs add <1% demand in high-penetration regions. Smart charging and V2G tech enhance grid stabilityÂ
4. Where is the cost of running an electric car vs petrol highest?
Austria, Italy, and Qatar due to low petrol prices and/or expensive electricity.
5. How does cold weather impact EV running costs?
Range drops ~40% in freezing temps, increasing energy costs. Preconditioning batteries mitigates this.
đź’ˇ The Verdict
The cost of running electric car vs petrol favors EVs in 90% of global markets by 2025. While petrol wins on sticker price, EVs’ £600–£1,500/year fuel savings, 50% lower maintenance, and tax incentives deliver £10,000–£20,000 lifetime savings. Exceptions exist in regions with ultra-cheap petrol or coal-heavy grids, but battery-cost declines will erase even these by 2027.
Maximize your savings: Use our interactive calculator to compare models in your region—factoring local fuel prices, taxes, and incentives!